Expat employers not in favour of gratuity for maids

According to a new law in the country, domestic helpers will be entitled to an end-of-service gratuity. However, expat employers are not in favour of giving such benefits to their house help, which they believe will be a further financial burden on them.

“It’s definitely not a good thing. They anyways take their weekly offs but gratuity is over doing things. I will have to pay if it’s illegal but something which I don’t like,” said A Pradhan, an Indian expat in the UAE.

Many other expat employers that this website spoke with agree that gratuity will be just putting too much pressure on already over-burdened residents in terms of housing, visa costs and schooling expenses.

“If the law states that there should be end-of-term benefits for maids then why not state that they cannot blackmail employers in giving them a hike every year? I’ve been giving my maid a 20 per cent hike every year for the last three years.

It’s much more than the salary set by the Indian consulate. She knows that I have a small baby and can extract more from me. Why does the law only state the minimum salary, what about the maximum slab, over which the maids should not get?” asked another resident living in The Springs area.

“I don’t know how good or bad it is,” said a German national living in the same area. “I wouldn’t mind paying the maid extra but why not reduce the hiring costs of the maid?” she asked.

However, the maids seem an elated a lot. “I will immediately tell my madam,” said a Sri Lankan maid, working for a South African family in Emirates Living. “She will have to pay me,” she added.

Now that the law has come into force, expats are averse to the idea but a poll run on the subject last week by this website tells another story.

The Emirates 24|7 poll last week revealed that majority of UAE residents were open to such an idea.

Majority (65 per cent) of the respondents believed giving the maids’ benefits like gratuity is only just. They work hard like any other employee, and so should be treated in the same manner, they opted to say.

Many in the country were already giving such benefits to maids even when there no legal implications in place. Discussions on popular forums show that many domestic helpers are getting their dues just like any other employee.

Even though the majority of the online readers said giving more financial rights to the maids is just, there is a section of people, who believe the fees in hiring a maid are already exorbitant, leaving no scope for extra expenses.

The poll run by this website showed that 26 per cent of the online respondents will not give gratuity to the maids as they believe there are many added costs in hiring a domestic help. At the same time 9 per cent said they are not sure about the right approach to the subject.

MUST READ:

Dubai maids wage doubles even as residents salaries stagnate

 

UAE residents ready to pay gratuity to maids

 

Full-time maids almost unaffordable: residents


 

  • Twitter
  • submit to reddit

Comments

  • Strange 14 June 2012 13:41 3 1
    @TF, Naimadz, Aaron: For some, hiring a maid is not a luxury but a necessity, as is the case with all working moms. There are no nurseries for babies less than 2 years old, and the ones that are for elder kids are way too expensive. Gratuity in itself is not wrong, but the overall cost is going beyond reasonable, especially the visa cost for a maid, which is not given to the maid but the authorities.
  • TF 13 June 2012 23:47 10 4
    Maids are just employees like you and me. We always look for better salaries etc. Why they should be deprived of the benefits. If the employer is cannot effort to pay such benefits they should not hire maids. They themselves should manage their housework. Maids also have their families and children, they sacrifice their familiy members and children by staying away from them to earn their livelyhood. It will be curse on ourselves if we ill treat them.
  • Naimadz 13 June 2012 23:38 11 3
    They should get same treatment like all of us including time offl... they are employees like us. If it gets too expensive then we need to do without... this is luxury and not meant for low wage earners to have helpers. Logical.
  • Arron 13 June 2012 15:12 13 3
    I bet the same expats arguing against paying their maids gratuity would fight their own employers tooth and nail for their own gratuity and the ones complaining about the cost of living already being high etc etc, maybe they should not have maids and they would save themselves all that money but would have to do all the maids work themselves. Maids should have the same rights and benefits as everyone else
  • PParker 13 June 2012 13:32 14 0
    Why isnt there a poll on whether the maid fees should be reduced or increased? I agree Maids should be treated just as employers law, holiday pay, tickets back home etc.. But Maid Visa cost should be same as employer Visa.
  • unfair 13 June 2012 13:09 7 0
    I agree with paying maids gratuity but its unfair for the government to ask us to do so when costs of employing them are so high. Its a financial burden on so many expats in dubai. Especially most of them living hand to mouth & have no other choice. There will be no illegal maids in Dubai, Lots of maids will get jobs & will be able to provide for thier families back home if the government does sowething about the employment costs. Hope we are heard & not just read
  • Zara 13 June 2012 12:20 9 0
    @Strange: Agree with you. Decrease the Dh5,000 fee for hiring and renewing maid's visa. This is the reason why more people hiring illegal maids.
  • Strange 13 June 2012 12:07 12 0
    Gratuity to housemaids? Then why not let the cost of their employment visas be in line with other workers in UAE?

Have your say

Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual/s whose content is submitted. DMI accepts no responsibility for the content of comment/s, including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

By submitting your comments you agree to this website's Terms & Conditions

Type in the characters you see in the picture below.

Videos

Follow
Emirates 24|7

Follow
Emirates 24|7
Google+ Facebook Twitter RSS

Most Popular in News

Latest jobs available

More jobs on Emirates 24|7

In Case You Missed It ...