Who are better drivers: men or women?

We have the statistics – you decide

Statistics don’t lie. Though those on the receiving end of such stats will insist they don’t always give you the correct picture.

Either way, the General Department of Traffic at Dubai Police today released statistics that list accidents caused by men and women motorists.

It might stoke the age-old debate of who is the better/safer driver… woman or man?

According to the statistics made available by Major General Mohammed Saif Al Zafeen, the Director of the General Department of Traffic at Dubai Police, 194 accidents were cause by women since the beginning of 2010, compared to 1,720 accidents caused by men.

Women were responsible for 20 per cent of total accidents caused in the last17 months killing 14 people and injuring 323, while in the same period male drivers caused 191 deaths and 2694 injuries.

In the first five months of this year women were behind 53 accidents, accounting for only 9.78 per cent of total accidents caused, while men caused 481 accidents during the same period.

While only seven died in accidents caused by women, 47 were killed in accidents committed by men.

Last year women were involved in 141 mishaps, or 10.14% of the total accidents.

While the total number of male and female drivers on Dubai was not available, the report stated that though women are considered relatively safer on roads compared to their male counterparts, accidents caused be females have slowly increased over the past few years, according to the report.

 “Our main goal is to ensure safety of roads for all motorists and we will take violators to task without differentiating between men and women,” Major General Al Zafeen said, however, adding that most women are safer on road then men.

Recounting one of the incidents that shocked him, Major Al Zafeen said, “I saw a car moving recklessly on Al Ittihad and chased it when approached I was shocked to see a woman was driving it. She was driving so dangerously it looked as if she would hit any car at any moment. She was not adhering to any law and when stopped she justified it saying she was getting late for a party.”

He pointed out that any kind of emergency doesn’t justify reckless driving and nobody has a right to put lives of other motorists in danger.

He warned that anybody found involved in rash driving would be arrested and their vehicles would be impounded.

  • Twitter

Comments

  • Matt 10 February 2012 15:16 0 0
    I love how all the white men support women drivers and the brown boys despise it... Insecure much?
  • Val 21 July 2011 20:17 0 0
    oooooo, don't take it personally!!!!!
  • koko 20 July 2011 09:34 0 0
    women
  • Rustam Ali 19 July 2011 15:39 0 0
    You never know when women are turning left or right. Surprise is always waiting for you, if you draw up behind of lady :) Then accidents, but no women involved... she is already driven away...
  • habby 19 July 2011 11:05 1 0
    Women are the resposible for the accidents, because I notice men stare at women while driving and cause accidents.
  • Qamar Zaman 19 July 2011 07:51 0 0
    Things may be right in this way but we have to it in another way as well. %age of women doing accidents will be much higher with respect to total number of women driving the vehicles. Figure of female accidents is low because their ratio of vehicles driven is also low as compare to the males.
  • Matt 18 July 2011 22:53 0 0
    Maybe men make accidents more than women, but I believe that most of the reasons of accidents are women. I myself prefer to change a lane if there is a woman driving in the next lane or in front of me!!! Since they want to be very careful and slow, that makes traffic and accidents.
  • Josephus Hap 18 July 2011 18:18 0 0
    Most of the schoolbus drivers in the USA and Canada are women. My wife was a schoolbus driver for 25 years, she caused never an accident. The driver's test for schoolbus is the most difficult.
  • Shabbir 18 July 2011 15:57 0 0
    Most of the accidents may be caused by men, but... what you fail to mention is the cause of those accidents are due to the women in the passenger seat telling men how to drive and thereby distracting them... hahahahha... take that women :)
  • Raj 18 July 2011 15:47 0 0
    Ok, but can the RTA please tell us the number of male and female drivers. This comparison should be a fair one. Else this 20:80 doesn't make any sense!
  • Sam 18 July 2011 15:22 0 0
    In Dubai, most of the women drive in second line of a freeway and slowly causing traffic jam. They should move to 4th or 5th line on Sheikh Zayed Road especially. This is applicable to all those driving slow on second line.
  • Akbar 18 July 2011 15:09 0 0
    Is there anyone who ever thought of the purpose of driving for each of man and woman? Especially in this region where the men are responsible person for earning bread... If a man drives a little faster than the speed limit, he might do so to cover the battle between time and bills. But how about the woman who will not share this tension with man in most cases?
  • Haromalaine 18 July 2011 14:37 0 0
    There's no one else... accident is accidents...
  • Khudai Nazar 18 July 2011 14:36 0 0
    If there is 20% man drivers & 80% woman, surely 95% accidents will be occurred by woman.
  • Mohammad 18 July 2011 14:19 0 0
    Small Scorpio or big Scorpio both has the same level of poison. Women and men are equally responsible for the accident whoever makes the mistake.
  • Khudai Nazar 18 July 2011 14:09 0 0
    I'm not against the women but they are not good in anything. Well, DRIVING, from 4 years in Dubai, I've seen only 2 female drivers driving perfectly. Woman are safer driver? They can't park the car properly even. :p
  • Flames 18 July 2011 13:48 0 0
    You cannot only compare statistics of how many women caused accidents. Compare how many women drive and how many of them cause accidents. Truth is, women are generally safer. But if you give a woman an expensive car (especially younger women) they drive very rash and are really rude. If you ever give way to one of them they probably will flip you off. And many times I've had one of them drive up behind me and flash even though I have nowhere to go (neither change lane nor go faster).
  • Asim 18 July 2011 13:31 0 0
    How about what percentage of women drivers cause accidents. If out of a 100 women 10 caused accidents and out of 1,000 men 100 caused accidents then the ratio is the same.
  • Andrew 18 July 2011 13:31 0 0
    Of course, women are the better drivers, isn't that right, darling? Will I still have my clothes ironed for tomorrow and my dinner on the table tonight?
  • Shan 18 July 2011 13:18 0 0
    Can you even call this statistics? It should be based on number of accidents caused by a gender on basis of total number of drivers in that gender. if women drivers are 10% of the total drivers in the country obviously the stats will show less number of accidents by women.

Have your say

Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual/s whose content is submitted. DMI accepts no responsibility for the content of comment/s, including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

By submitting your comments you agree to this website's Terms & Conditions

Videos

Follow
Emirates 24|7

Follow
Emirates 24|7
Google+ Facebook Twitter RSS

Most Popular in News

Latest jobs available

More jobs on Emirates 24|7

Editor's Choice

In Case You Missed It ...