Skycourts residents refuse to pay ‘unreasonable’ chiller fees

Owners plan legal action; Alpha offers flexible payment option to ‘defaulters’

Hundreds of residents in Skycourts project in Dubailand are up in arms against the high chiller charges, but say they are willing to pay if the charges are ‘reasonable’.

“The chiller charges are very high and we are unable to understand the exact charges since the metre readings are not clear. We, however, are not against paying, but the charges have to be reasonable. We are not defaulting… we are just delaying the payment,” an owner-resident told 'Emirates24|7' on condition of anonymity.

“The cooling unit opposite of Tower C is small compared to district cooling plants [such as Empower, etc] elsewhere in the city – leading to an impression that it is a chiller unit and not district cooling at all,” he added.

Residents have been holding meetings for months with the preceding one being held a few days back where they sought to take an unified view on whether to take legal action against the parties involved with the development of the project which consists of 2,836 apartments in six high-rise towers.

“There are over 200 residents who have joined hands and have decided to move the court to get justice. We are in talks with a lawyer and charting on our future course of action,” another resident said.

Apartment owners claim they have signed contracts with the developer whereby Empower will be providing district cooling services. However, the service is being offered by Alpha Utilities.

“All of sudden, we got the bills from this company called Alpha… we don’t know who they are, and also the bills are not transparent,” informed MS, an apartment owner.

Alpha Utilities, in a detailed statement, sent to 'Emirates24|7' refuted owners’ claim that Empower was supposed to provide district cooling services. “No specifics were ever communicated in relation to the provider of district cooling. The provisions for district cooling were an integral part of all the original sales and purchase agreements which were signed by all owners,” Alpha Utilities management said.

“The contract clearly states that the chilled water for air-conditioning purposes will be provided exclusively through the master developer and the owners agree to enter into any agreeents for the provisions of such services as required by the developer, and that the purchaser shall be responsible for and pay for any fees for such chilled water levied.”

Alpha said the consumption was calculated in-line with the common standard practices for district cooling.

“We received a few complaints in relation to the frequency of the billing cycles, which was initially every six months which is a common practice in district cooling billing. In fact, some district cooling service providers have annual billing cycles.

“Nevertheless, and based on an official request from the project owners association, we agreed to revise the billing cycle and started sending bills on a monthly basis. We have also agreed to offer residents the option to settle the outstanding amounts from their first billing cycle in flexible installments.”

Another objection raised by residents was that Alpha had given the defaulters a notice of disconnection in the event the bills were not paid by March 15. On the issue, the company said it was willing to meet the tenants who need further clarifications on the nature of the district cooling billing.

“Like any service provider, we hold our rights to disconnect the service if any client refuses to pay his or her dues on time. However, this is an absolute final resort and we always ensure that we have sent sufficient reminders before disconnecting the service,” the company stated.

 

 

  • Twitter
  • submit to reddit

Comments

  • Shanks 30 August 2012 12:03 1 0
    I have been living in Sky Court since April 2012 and found the utility services atrocious. Despite repeated requests, they still have not connected by TV cable yet. And, they provided me with one key for the main door of the apartment and refused to give the keys to the bedroom saying that it is with the contractor and he cannot be located. What utter nonsense. Above all, Alpha bills are not transparent at all. I have no clue about my chiller usage at all. The bill does not state my usage.
  • Rizwan 18 July 2012 15:36 0 6
    My AC cooling is disconnected by Alpha and they have confirmed it. I have an infant at home. The AC bill is 4000+
  • Marcus 12 May 2012 11:18 2 1
    In addition to that, TV Satellite antenna in tower B is not working since we moved in almost 3 months ago so most of the TV channels are not received. Management is just turning a blind eye on that issue. Harbor supposedly the management company is not responding to telephones or emails. One person told me to call SIBCA which is the company responsible for the maintaining the antenna. When I did, they told me that they should not be contacted directly by me, and they did nothing as well.
  • fadi 17 April 2012 19:12 6 0
    I really become a crazy man when I heard that I have to pay around 2.4k as cooling charge for the last 6 months. some one have to look at us from the authorities in Dubai to solve this issue for us.
  • Haja 6 March 2012 16:24 3 0
    We are 2 living in the apartment, one have a card and other don't have, we have to pay Dh2,000 to get additional card, various reasons, I look out for some new location in Surook Mirdif, Al Khail Gate at reasonable rent and cooling free of charges, plus close access to cities around...
  • Haja 6 March 2012 16:22 2 0
    I am a tenant at Skycourt 1 b/r room apartment. There is mentioned in the contract capacity and consumption charges. However, there is nothing saying at what rate these charges based, we can take as 0.00001 or they can take it 1000.00 PER UNIT.
  • T 29 February 2012 18:53 3 1
    What would you expect to get from such companies... Read your contracts before you sign them. Read your contracts!!! You will not get anywhere if you have signed blindly and agreed to terms and conditions they impose on you.
  • Sanal 29 February 2012 18:47 0 2
    I live in Gardens and they have raised prices there... the bill for my two bedroom for January is Dh1,350 and cooling charge part is Dh1,200! That means yearly it is AED 13,000... plus I have signed my rent contract without reading it too.. I'll move to Skycourt if the fixed charges are less. Dh500-600 per month means I pay 50% less than what I pay now.
  • BNP 29 February 2012 13:36 3 0
    The exisitng equipment so called will not be sufficient to meet the requirement if the cooupancy rate is more thab 60% during summer. So even if you pay the bill also the required colloing won't be there! They need to really work out some alternative solution! NB may easily escape form this situation as the maintenance period is going to finish by this month and they simply will say wash out as the Districct Cooling part of Master Developer's and not their responsibilty.
  • Ion 29 February 2012 10:43 4 0
    We should get the Consumer protection involved in this. basically, they have the meters but what they say is that they do not want to use it. Dear Alpha it is like this: you tell me the price and then i decide how much i use, not the other way round
  • Jagan 29 February 2012 10:17 3 0
    Ishfaq - If you want to know the difference between Chiller and district cooling unit then please talk any of the resident of skycourts they have mastered the subject expect for alpha staffs.It is good that tenants do not pay for cooling and install there own AC as in summer present second hand cooler cannot feed 2800 apartment.Why pay when you know in summer it will not work.
  • Nelson 29 February 2012 09:40 9 0
    The managment did big mistake, they installed chiller instead of district cooling. Chiller unit required power 1.7kw/TR and disric cooling required only 0.8kw/TR Because of this change power consumption almost 2.5 times more. And they try to charge us the diference. They charging capacity charges AED 250.00 for 1BHK. This considering as day light robberry.
  • Khan 29 February 2012 09:16 3 1
    The Chiller is one issue, then there is water leakage, blocked garbage chutes, unplanned water drainage, no proper surrounding infrastructure, no permanant gaurds, some gaurds dont bother and open doors for everyone coming to the building, improper parking, noisy mechanics that are heard through walls. So many issues yet no one is doing anything about it. I hope atleast the chiller issue is resolved soon.
  • Sashi 29 February 2012 01:18 3 0
    Also understand the chiller provided is only one-third the capacity that is required to cool skycourts apartments. So inspite of having the chiller on, it will be hot from April onwards as it was during the previous summer.
  • Jagan 28 February 2012 18:01 10 0
    Adel you said is right. Make it at par with DEWA no one will object.
  • Mohan 28 February 2012 17:58 7 0
    I started staying in the apartment in JAN 12 . The first bill I received was from JUL11 to NOV 30 for about AED 3000. Makes me feel my apartment was sublet unofficially.
  • Ishfaq 28 February 2012 17:37 0 22
    One has to understand the difference of Split Unit and Central Cooling System provided by District Cooling Providers (quality of building environment, its impact on environment etc). Secondly, it was our commercial decision to buy property in Skycourts with these terms. Moreover, we are lucky to some extent to have received handover, as Skycourts continued construction even during crisis. Look at all the developments around you.
  • Adel 28 February 2012 16:29 10 0
    The fixed capacity of upto Dhs350 plus consumption charges for a 2 BHK charged is irrespective whether the apartment is occupied or vacant is absolutely unreasonable. No one will object if it is made in line with DEWA charges in much sought-after localities of Bur Dubai & Karama.
  • RR 28 February 2012 16:13 5 0
    We have documents from Skycourts, which explicitly says that the 'District Cooling' services will be provided by Empower. We have now been provided by basic chiller units & being charged more than District Cooling rates prevalent in places like DIFC, Healthcare City etc where District Cooling is provided.
  • Lakshi 28 February 2012 16:11 6 0
    Best part it that Skycourts is a part of National Bond. NB should come forward and discuss the matter with the officials of Alpha.

Have your say

Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual/s whose content is submitted. DMI accepts no responsibility for the content of comment/s, including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

By submitting your comments you agree to this website's Terms & Conditions

Type in the characters you see in the picture below.

Videos

Most Popular in Property

Follow
Emirates 24|7

Follow
Emirates 24|7
Google+ Facebook Twitter RSS

Latest jobs available

More jobs on Emirates 24|7

In Case You Missed It ...