Banks and financial institutions in the region need to look more closely at "economic capital", which is a measure of risk, rather than merely focusing on traditional measures of capital adequacy, said economists and risk analysts.

Based on a "probabilistic assessment of potential future losses", economic capital is a more forward looking measure of capital adequacy than traditional accounting measures, the economists opined.

Traditional measures of capital adequacy relate existing capital levels to assets or some form of adjusted assets, while economic capital relates capital to risks, regardless of the existence of assets. "We are pointing to the fact that regulatory capital should be distinguished from economic capital which is more risk related. So banks should be looking at not only the regulatory part of it but also the economic capital, that is, measuring the amount of capital being used taking into account the risks that they are facing. Adopting the economic capital concept at the level of our banks and financial institutions is necessary," Dr Nasser Al Saidi, Chief Economist, DIFC Authority, told Emirates Business.

Banks typically have internal models, which they have been using for regulatory capital. While there has been some discussion on the concept of economic capital, the same has not evolved much. It is time that banks look more closely at it, he added.

The economic crisis brought forth the importance of effective risk management in the financial sector. Traditional measures, said the analysts, have not really helped determine and control the risks that financial institutions and banks stand exposed to. Even as a host of stress tests exist at the moment, the analysts called for a review and reform of the same.

"This is the first time that this region has faced as critical a crisis as the current one. We feel it is time our banking and financial system should be adopting various stress testing tools to manage and mitigate risks. The traditional measures are important. They give you a snapshot of where the economy stands vis-a-vis the standards. But they won't be able to tell you that you could fail," said Dr Saidi.

Majority of the banks in the region, which are more exposed to global risks as they expand, are yet to develop stress testing tools that would hold good under different scenarios, the analysts noted, while emphasising the need to incorporate financial vulnerability indicators into their decision-making and risk-management strategies so as to combat the effects of the crisis.

"The unprecedented volatility in financial and money markets and increased economic uncertainty caused by the global economic crisis makes it critical for banks and financial institutions to identify, measure and monitor their vulnerability to a range of factors and to extreme variations or outcomes of those risk factors. For central banks and regulators, which have to deal with financial soundness at the level of individual banks as well as mitigate systemic risk, the crisis has highlighted the need to assess the effectiveness of financial vulnerability indicators and to develop new early warning and financial vulnerability indicators to enhance their risk and mitigation capabilities," said Dr Saidi.

While asserting that policymakers make judgements well in time, Dr Fabio Scacciavillani, Director of Macroeconomics and Statistics, DIFC Authority, said timely availability of data was critical. He said economic capital is the best estimate of readily accessible resources, which financial institutions need to maintain in order to avoid bankruptcy. "It can be seen also as a risk adjusted measure of capital used to cover exposure and to allocate the cost of maintaining regulatory capital among different units within the organisation," he said.

As financial institutions and banks in the Gulf become more internationally connected, it is critical to look at global economic and market risks that we stand exposed to rather than just traditional sources of stress testing balance sheets like interest rates or like forex rate changes, said Dr Saidi.

The risk management function in banks has become much more critical than it was earlier. "So adopt new techniques, inform your boards much more about the nature of the risks, stress test your balance sheets, and look at new ways of estimating how much capital you should have. The regulatory capital that you have is one indicator of how much capital you require. But look at economic capital is also an additional element that boards of banks or financial institutions should be looking at," he added.

The traditional ways of stress testing, said Scacciavillani, were "merely a debate between two or three best case scenarios" without adequate consideration of vulnerabilities or downside possibilities. The traditional approach has seen three elements contributing to a stable financial system- adequate macro-prudential surveillance, effective supervision and sound financial infrastructure and systems, said Dr Saidi.

"Given the current economic environment, it is even more important for financial institutions conditioning risk models' outcomes to macroeconomic factors, in order to test the resilience of their financial structure over adverse stages of the economic cycle," said Cristiano Zazzara, Global Head of RiskMetrics Group's Banking Business. Elaborating on probable rise in risks, Zazzara said mean default rate increased from 1.6 per cent to 4.98 per cent from 1998 to 2001, whereas mean recovery rate decreased from 41.1 per cent to 23.34 per cent during this period.

With a view to ensure stability, the Dubai Financial Services Authority has increased emphasis on management processes and people and stress testing in capital adequacy assessments and evaluations, said Bryan Stirewalt, Director, Supervision, DFSA. "We are increasing our supervisory regime on how we visit the firms, particularly onsite transaction testing," he said.

 

Keep up with the latest business news from the region with the Emirates Business 24|7 daily newsletter. To subscribe to the newsletter, please click here.