Abu Dhabi, Dubai, Cairo and Casablanca are best positioned to attract more long-term regional and global investment into their real estate markets over the next two to three years, according to Jones Lang LaSalle (JLL).
"While some of these Tier 1 markets may see a continued decline in short-term performance, they are considered to offer the right combination of investment competitiveness, real estate market conditions and asset specific ingredients to attract long-term investors," the global real estate consultancy said in a Mena House View report for September.
Strong performers
A number of the cities that investors expect to record the strongest performing real estate markets over the next 12 months ( such as Riyadh, Jeddah and Doha) are classified as Tier 2 cities in terms of their appeal to long-term investors. However, their attractiveness is constrained by relatively high current pricing and the limited availability of investable product.
In an earlier February report, JLL predicted 2009 would be a year of correction, with the markets moving into a stabilisation phase in 2010, ahead of a recovery in 2011.
"While we expect to see a further consolidation in the real estate sector, with prices and rents continuing to decline in some markets over the short term, the pace of correction is now easing as global and regional economic stability leads to an improvement in investor sentiment. A key to the success of markets in this phase of the cycle will be their ability to attract long-term regional and global investment.
"This transition will require a paradigm shift, from the previous reliance on short-term strategies and rapid implementation, to an increased focus on the creation of quality real estate assets that will be attractive to both occupiers and long-term real estate investors," the report said.
Mature economies
In mature economies, long- term investors (including private family groups, conglomerates, government entities, and institutional investors such as insurance companies, pension funds and listed real estate funds) account for about 80 per cent of large real estate investment transactions. These groups bring high volumes of relatively stable, long-term capital to the real estate sector. Along with LaSalle Investment Management, JLL has identified a range of criteria that these long-term investors typically consider when assessing any potential real estate transaction. These criteria can be grouped together into three broad headings: investment environment competitiveness, real estate market conditions and availability of investable product.
Speculative investors tend to be relatively opportunistic in nature, attaching the greatest weighting to the third set of largely asset specific criteria. In contrast, long term institutional real estate investors tend to take a more "top down" approach, beginning with the competitiveness of the economy and the real estate sector of any market, before moving on to identify particular assets.
Before considering the specifics of the real estate markets themselves, long- term institutional investors will typically assess the broader macro economic and investment environment within which the real estate markets operate. The challenge here is for governments and regulators to build a transparent investment and business environment to encourage employment and population growth, which will then attract long-term real estate investors.
The second set of factors considered by long-term investors relate more specifically to the real estate markets themselves. In its Mena House View report in March, JLL identified a series of 17 factors that will impact the timing of the recovery of real estate markets.
"While definite progress has been made, creating the right environment to promote the recovery of the real estate market [and thereby attract more long-term investment] clearly remains a 'work in progress'."
Dubai, however, has made considerable progress since last year. There are no longer any red lights, with the market being characterised by a mix of amber and the emergence of a few green lights, suggesting progress has been made on all the factors and some have now seen recovery achieved.
Leading indicators
As would be expected, "leading indicators" such as equity markets and energy prices have recovered first, with other indicators (such as employment and occupier demand) lagging behind. The real estate market is itself a lagged indicator and while JLL expects further declines in both values and rental levels to occur over the rest of 2009, the pace of decline is certainly easing.
Despite the improvement in sentiment and the emerging consensus that the Dubai market is through the worst of the crisis, one significant challenge remains – the potential oversupply that is emerging in many sectors of the market. Vacancies in the office market are currently about 25 per cent and the average occupancy rate in the hotel market has fallen to about 65 per cent. The oversupply situation is likely to get worse before it gets better in some sectors and this will continue to place downward pressure on prices and rental levels in the short term. This is likely to lead to a "two tier" investment market, with continued demand for those properties that are well leased and provide a secure income flow, while there will be little interest from long-term investors in projects under construction or those suffering low occupancy levels, the report said.
The third set of factors required to attract long term investors relate specifically to the real estate sector itself and the availability (or otherwise) of investable quality real estate product. Despite the dramatic correction in pricing in markets such as Dubai and the more subdued corrections elsewhere in the Mena region, selling has not proved to be easy and few major deals have occurred to date. Attracting long-term investors into the market requires more than just competitive pricing, existing owners must also adopt a changed mindset, in line with the new (longer term) investment paradigm referred to above.
Pricing concerns
"With the majority of owners continuing to adopt a 'wait and hold' strategy in the expectation of a future rebound, pricing is often still not in line with market expectations. Even where pricing is competitive, assets are not being packaged in a way that provides the secure long-term leases required to underpin the stable cash flow sought by investors."
Those owners that recognise the importance of securing quality tenants on long term leases and implementing more proactive asset and facility management programmes will be those that succeed in selling their assets to long-term investors that are currently searching for opportunities.
One of the major hurdles to creating more investable product is short-term leases that continue to prevail across most markets in the Mena region. In this regard it is encouraging that average commercial leases in the Dubai market have increased from one to three years and that a number of owners of commercial premises are now openly talking about the prospect of offering tenants longer term leases (up to 10 years). This would make any asset much more attractive and therefore saleable to the new breed of long-term investors that the markets need to attract if they are to progress to the next level in their real estate maturity.
So what can existing owners do at the asset level to attract regional and international investors? The answer is to make products and portfolios investable, through a practical and realistic approach to the pricing.
Keep up with the latest business news from the region with the Emirates Business 24|7 daily newsletter. To subscribe to the newsletter, please click here.