Smaller developers will continue to have difficulties raising funds for hotel projects as banks are reluctant to provide loans for this asset class, according to a senior analyst.

"Life is hard for small developers," John Podaris, Associate Director of Tri Hospitality Consulting, told Emirates Business. "They will be looking to the private equity market – and the private equity market is particularly risk averse at this time.

"Banks will look at secure, high-end and very sustainable developments. Liquidity will take a while to filter through to the market – I don't see that happening until after 2010."

The first tranche of the Dubai bond issue had been used to service existing lending arrangements, he said.

"You know, mainly defaulters – people who needed to refinance," he added.

"That just got soaked up. Everyone is hoping that the second tranche will find its way into the market and ease the shortage of liquidity."

Podaris said banks remained cautious. "First of all they are governed by fairly strict and very good Central Bank rules about lending. Secondly, banks tend to focus on the customers that generate the best business for them."

He said the banks would focus on customers with marketable projects, clients they had established long-term relationships with and semi-governmental institutions. "The private equity market is looking at returns in the region of 20 to 25 per cent from distressed sales, which covers their risk. But a hotel cannot generate this kind of return even with reduced construction costs. Hotels typically produce an internal rate of return (IRR) of anything between 13 and 16 per cent, so market expectations are way above what a hotel can generate."

Podaris said investors who were cash rich were also looking for a high IRR.

"We don't believe they would turn to the hospitality sector. They tend to focus on industry and other sectors.

"Hospitality always takes a long time to recover [from a downturn]. Investment in a hotel project is about long-term cash flow and is not about an early exit strategy. One tends to invest in hospitality in the upswing of the cycle and that balances your portfolio.

"You will have some very high-risk investments with very high returns. Then you have a healthy hospitality portfolio that balances the high risk with better cash returns."

Podaris said there would be increasing demand for small city centre hotels that occupy niche markets, such as those in Al Barsha. But there was still a need for large mixed-use developments. "You are now starting to look at cities such as Abu Dhabi and Dubai, which are starting to mature and develop these modern centres. A good mixed-use development is self-contained in terms of demand generation, with hotels and retail outlets all feeding into each other. This makes a lot more sense than putting up a shopping mall on Sheik Zayed Road and a big five-star hotel somewhere else.

"The downside is that the investment for a mixed-use development is enormous and a lot of them were cancelled because of the financial crisis."

Amine Hamdani, Vice-President of real estate consultancy CBRE Hotels, said foreign investors were showing interest in Dubai's secondary market for hotels.

"Though the number of transactions in Dubai is still low there is a lot of interest among investors in properties here. Many foreign investors are looking at Dubai with interest. Typically the type of property that catches the eye of investors is a hotel with more than 120 rooms that is valued at anything

between $60 million (Dh220m) and $200m, depending on the location."

Hamdani said investors were looking for income-generating and operational hotels in good locations. Newly-developed hotels or those in the pipeline were of less interest to international buyers.

"It still makes sense to invest in the hotels market across the region and several opportunities are available for cash-rich investors. Very few hotel investment deals have happened as the industry in this region has been dominated by developers, not investors."

Two basic types of hotels come onto the market. The first is a property run by a multinational chain with attractive location and good cash flow. The second is a hotel that is badly managed, is in a bad location and needs rebranding.

The first type attracts investors looking for a good level of return without operational involvement who would be able to benefit from the expertise of the management company, the brand and the current cash flow. Likely investors include real estate funds, pension and government funds, hotel funds, holdings targeting diversification and banks.

"The IRR for this investment would be above nine per cent," said Hamdani. "The other investment would attract investors with a higher risk profile or hoteliers targeting poorly performing properties."

Earlier estimates indicated that 65,000 new hotel rooms would be needed in the next seven to eight years. But because of the economic crisis the number of extra rooms required in the next five years is just 22,000 – 30.8 per cent of the original forecast.

"The market has been hit by adverse conditions in the real estate market as several mixed-use developments that included hotels have been stopped or delayed," said Hamdani.

In May, the Dubai-based market research firm Proleads, said the UAE hotel sector will see Dh73.45 billion of cash flow into projects under execution this year.

Proleads Director Emil Rademeyer said: "The economic slowdown has resulted in much more cash flowing out of the hotel construction sector than into it."

The GCC countries are currently building 306 hotels worth more than $140bn. Proleads forecasts the cash flow into the region's hotel projects will be approximately $30bn in 2010, marginally up from the 2009 estimate of $28bn. In 2008, the total was along similar lines – $26bn.

And about five per cent of the 893 planned hotel projects have been cancelled, according to Proleads.

 

Keep up with the latest business news from the region with the daily Emirates Business 24|7 newsletter. To subscribe to the newsletter, please click here.