The buzz at the Frankfurt Motor Show last week was definitely electric. The auto industry has latched onto electric as a future substitute for petrol engines and there were numerous new electric cars on show. There was also the usual array of supercars and luxury marques with Bentley, Rolls Royce and Lamborghini unveiling new models.
Given the horror year that the auto industry had just experienced, launching top-end models now is a risk but there will be plenty of people hoping the confidence shown by these companies is not misplaced. The car industry could do with some good news.
Only construction and banking have fared worse than the auto industry in this global economic downturn. Families over-encumbered with debt have, understandably, been unwilling to splash out tens of thousands of euros, dollars or dirhams on new cars. And even those who do want to buy have found that financing has largely disappeared, making the task that much harder. The result of all this has been a collapse in sales, factories have been idle and mega-companies such as General Motors have been forced into bankruptcy.
Various "cash-for-clunker" type schemes have been introduced and have achieved success in the United States and Europe but underlying sales remain weak and recovery is still some way off. In addition to this short-term crisis, the auto industry is also grappling with the expensive long-term problem of how to replace petrol with something more eco-friendly.
Hybrids were a useful temporary solution but the industry has now moved on to pure electric (or plug-in electric hybrids) as the way to save the world. At Frankfurt last week, Renault, the French automaker, became the latest automaker to unveil a range of electrics, which will be available from 2011.
Renault has also developed an interesting business model for refuelling its electric cars. Rather than force drivers to plug their car into the mains every night, drivers will be able to go to a special garage where an automated system will replace the empty battery pack with a full one. The system will be paid for via a subscription and it has the potential to free electric cars from the constraints of a 12-hour refuelling cycle.
This idea is somewhat similar to the iPhone business model and is potentially a brilliant solution that could be good for drivers but would also allow automakers to receive revenue from both the sale of the vehicle and from every refuelling stop.
This was clearly an important announcement by Renault – for both the company and the auto industry in general. But did anyone care? No. And the reason nobody was paying attention to Renault's electric cars was that what everyone really wanted to know about was last year's Singapore Grand Prix.
For those of you who have missed the latest Formula One scandal, the Renault team was accused by their former driver Nelson Piquet Jr of ordering him to crash during the Singapore race last year. Doing so forced out the safety car and some clever strategic thinking gifted a race win to Piquet's teammate Fernando Alonso.
The claims were initially denied but then, suddenly, the Renault company said it would not challenge Piquet's account of the F1 team's activities. Flavio Briatore, the team principle, resigned and the sporting world went into uproar.
This was cheating on a spectacular level. This was not just a simple case of taking illegal drugs. Rather, the plan was to crash an F1 car at more than 100mph into a concrete wall. The danger to Piquet, other drivers, marshals and spectators was intolerable.
The behaviour of the F1 team has now put intolerable pressure on its owner, Renault. The carmaker has enough difficulties to face without adding a scandal of this magnitude. In the current climate, consumers have enough reason not to buy a new car at the moment without adding concern over a company's reputation for cheating.
Renault has had a horrible year so far, losing €2.7 billion (Dh14.68bn) in the first six months alone. Its sales are down 16 per cent worldwide and even that figure has been helped by scrappage schemes in Europe. The French Government stepped in at the start of the year with a €3bn bailout package but this was linked to retaining work in France. The F1 scandal may make the French Government question whether its money should be used to support an elite sport that employs only a few hundred people (and mostly in the UK where the team is based).
BMW and Honda have already pulled out of F1 this year because they cannot justify the hundreds of millions of dollars it costs to run a team. Rumours about Renault's continued involvement were circulating even before this incident and even Toyota, the mightiest carmaker of them all, has been questioning its F1 commitment.
However, in the long run I believe that the most significant impact of this scandal will be in the damage done to Renault's electric launch. Carlos Ghosn, the Chief Executive, spent his time in Frankfurt answering questions about the F1 team when I am sure he would rather have been talking about his innovative electric strategy.
That said, Renault has done exactly the right thing in handling this sorry saga. The company got on top of the story quickly and admitted guilt, even if the eventual account of what happened in Singapore turns out to be less cut and dry than has been made out so far. Renault has not hidden and it has not tried to weasel out of trouble using dubious explanations that nobody would believe.
Sadly, however, there was only one Renault story last week and the charge being discussed was cheating, not electric. That is a great shame because Renault's approach to the problem of how to fuel the motorcars of the future deserves to be taken seriously because we will be dealing with the carbon issue long after we have forgotten the names of Nelson Piquet and Flavio Briatore.
- The writer is a Business Correspondent with The Times of London
Keep up with the latest business news from the region with the Emirates Business 24|7 daily newsletter. To subscribe to the newsletter, please click here.