There is a new term in the lexicon of real estate analysts and it is being heard increasingly these days – it is "double dip". This is a fear haunting realtors and developers in all commercial and residential markets alike, and it is a worry that national markets moving from the current malaise may then receive another shock, thus deterring sales and driving values still lower.

What is the likelihood of this happening? I will leave the broader issues to economists but to explore the specific real estate side, look at the UK residential market today.

Five of the six major price indices based on mortgage loans or sale prices show that UK house values are now rising, from a meagre 0.1 per cent in the past month to 1.6 per cent. Government figures based on completed transactions in recent months show rises, too, of more than one per cent in the second quarter of 2009. So far, so good. But look a little behind those headline figures and things are looking – well, better than before, but not on a path to sustained recovery. There are still only just 35,000 residential transactions a month, scarcely 25 per cent of the total in 2007, and estate agents in the small towns and cities outside London are less bullish on the future than their top-end equivalents. It is easy to see why.

In London, only 55 per cent of homes are bought with mortgages but elsewhere the figure is 75 per cent or even more – so with lending at its lowest level since 2000, there are few reasons to cheer, especially in locations with a lot of mid- to low-priced homes. Likewise worsening unemployment – up 750,000 in a year and still rising, mainly in areas outside of London – provides an unlikely economic backdrop to the housing boom that some say is now under way.

So while the UK housing market looks to be coming out of the recessionary dip, many fear that late in 2009 or early 2010 there will be that "double dip" of low transactions and falling prices as widespread unemployment kicks in and demand [now temporarily on the rise] drops back again to 2008 levels.

Similarly with the US commercial market. When the Moody's Real national commercial property index showed a fall of a modest one per cent in June [the latest data available] after two previous months each showing seven per cent drops, you could almost hear the relief on the other side of the Atlantic. This, surely, was the start of the upturn.

Well, maybe. But transactions are only six per cent of what they were at the peak of the US commercial market two-and-a-half years ago and many analysts say the arrival of major numbers of distress sales will do little except drive up the number of transactions and drive down the average price at which deals are concluded. Again, these doomsayers suggest, the dreaded double dip will become apparent in a few months time.

Personally, I am not so sure that these pundits are correct. There were eternal optimists around two years ago saying prices would not fall, transactions would not drop, and surely mortgage lending was here to stay at record levels. How wrong they were.

But now, equally, there are commentators who are making a very nice living out of perpetual pessimism. For them, every cloud has a darker lining still, suggesting even worse storms are on the way.

My hunch is that although some markets take longer to fall than others [remember what this column said just two weeks ago about the slow-motion price falls in eastern Europe that are now gathering momentum just as much of the rest of the world looks to be improving] most are now beginning to be on their way out.

But undue pessimism may yet derail growing confidence, frightening off transactions. And premature ending of fiscal stimuli by national governments may be similarly fatal to the well-being of commercial and residential real estate markets.

Allowing the banks to stand on their own two feet is a great idea when those institutions are stable – but are we at that point yet? Creating economic circumstances such that central banks raise interest rates may be a sign of improving national economies – but is there any country in that position already? The answer to both questions seems to me very clearly to be, no. Acting too quickly will allow those pessimists to get the upper hand and will encourage that dreaded double dip.

Instead, hold those stimuli in place, at least until we see that everyone is coming out of the single dip – and then we can have faith that there is no unwelcome downturn in 2010, too.


- The writer is a Property Correspondent with The London Observer

 

Keep up with the latest business news from the region with the Emirates Business 24|7 daily newsletter. To subscribe to the newsletter, please click here.