There is a quote from Theodore Roosevelt, delivered in Paris in 1910, that has never felt more relevant to English football than it does right now.

“It is not the critic who counts,” he said. “Not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena.”

Thomas Tuchel is in the arena. The men calling for his head are cowering behind their microphones and keyboards.

Let us be clear before we go any further. Tuchel made mistakes at this World Cup. His squad selection lacked the foresight to anticipate the injury and suspension toll that a tournament of this intensity invariably brings.

His logic was not without merit. He selected players he trusted to train with maximum intensity regardless of minutes, reasoning that big egos left idle become difficult egos. But when the injuries came, as they always do, the cover was not good enough. Players of greater quality had been left at home.

And then there was Argentina. A lead held for 30 minutes. Defensive substitutions that invited pressure. A lead surrendered in stoppage time. The decision was poor. It was fatal. He said it himself afterwards: “It is my scar.” You have to respect a man who wears it rather than hides it.

So yes, he made mistakes. This column will not pretend otherwise.

But here is the question the television studios refuse to ask: who else would you have?

This is a man who has won 12 trophies as a manager. The DFB-Pokal with Dortmund. Two Ligue 1 titles with PSG, plus the domestic cups. The Bundesliga with Bayern. And then the Champions League, the greatest prize in club football, whose final he reached in consecutive seasons with two different clubs. A feat no manager in the history of the competition had ever achieved.

He lost the final with PSG in 2020. He came back with Chelsea in 2021 and won it.

He has managed at the highest level in Germany, France and England, winning the domestic title in all three countries. He speaks the language. He understands the culture. He loves the game as it is played here.

He arrived and immediately produced England’s best qualifying campaign on record: eight wins from eight, without conceding a single goal. He took England to a World Cup semi-final at his first attempt, their best finish since 1966. They came third.

No England manager in history arrived with credentials remotely close to his. Not Ramsey. Not Venables. Not Eriksson. Not Capello. The man is uniquely qualified for the job he is doing.

And yet the loudest voices wanted him sacked. Over one substitution.

A World Cup is one of the most intense first-time experiences in football management. The compressed schedule. The elimination format. The weight of a nation. The best managers in history have stumbled at their first attempt.

What they do not do is repeat the same mistakes.

Only a fool believes Tuchel did not study every decision he made in that tournament and file it away. The squad selection will be better. The contingency planning will be sharper. The identity of the team in the closing stages of a knockout game will be more ruthless, more merciless, more certain of itself.

And if you need any further evidence of the man’s quality, look no further than last Sunday.

England went to Madrid, to the home of the world champions, and ended Spain’s 43-game unbeaten run. They led 3-0 before Elliot Anderson was sent off and Spain clawed it back to 3-2. Under ferocious pressure, in front of 55,000 hostile fans, 10 men held out.

It was a result of genuine substance against the best team on the planet, on their own ground.

The same pundits who were demanding Tuchel’s head in July are rather quieter this week. Some have already rewritten their position entirely. A man so certain of his verdict that he called for another man to lose his livelihood is now recanting because the results changed.

One can only imagine these same men in the arena, needing to rely on that conviction to make a key substitution, then flippantly trying to reverse their decision seconds after making it.

England have waited 60 years for a manager capable of ending that hurt. He is standing right in front of them. He is in the arena, absorbing the blows, taking the scars and bravely preparing to go again.

The man on the sofa should be grateful.

----

Nicholas Bull is a British real estate entrepreneur who has called Dubai home for 12 years. A lifelong sports fanatic, he talks all things sport and property.