Fair-value accounting, commonly referred to as mark to market, should be suspended as such requirement is not assisting markets to return to normality, a top official from the Dubai Financial Services Authority (DFSA) has proposed. According to DFSA CEO Paul Koster, the fair-value application is highly pro-cyclical and has an accelerative effect in driving markets down further. A moratorium in this regard will stop fair value feeding the vicious cycle without eliminating relevant information to the investor by means of its disclosure. He said this will allow time for the markets to return to normality and for international accounting standard-setting bodies to consider what needs to be done. "I say fair-value accounting should be suspended but with an additional requirement of the disclosure of the valuation means," Koster told Emirates Business. "I am much more in favour of a narrative communication with investors today than give the investors the idea that there is a needle-point position in a valuation, which is actually in today's market is not really possible." Koster said instead of using a needle-point precision of fair-value accounting, an improved disclosure paragraph in management's discussion and analysis on valuations can be more helpful. "I suggest that they suspend the requirement of fair-value application for the time being," he said. "However, in the disclosure, management will detail what they did and the ranges of valuations that are available in the market – have they seen similar products, similar investments – and decide whether that is in a range, which they feel is appropriate so that the investor can decide whether he or she agrees with the chosen valuation." Koster said the purpose of the proposed suspension is not to induce inconsistency or to create confusion in accounts, adding that the moratorium will not be allowed to continue beyond the point that is absolutely necessary, as it may lend itself to abuse from financial institutions when normalcy returns. The moratorium therefore needs to be lifted when the market is no longer distressed. "I consider market is stressed when you have price movements in market that go way beyond what is a reasonable movement," he said. "Look at what happened to Barclays for example – in one day it was 70 per cent down and four days later it was 70 per cent up with the same kind of information – that to me is a distressed market." "Would that be a precise moment to say that the market is no longer distressed? Everybody knows when the market is no longer distressed," he said. In a paper he has recently authored, Koster said when financial markets are active, prices traded on them reflect consensus between buyers and sellers about the future cash flows of financial instruments, and on the degree of uncertainty surrounding them. Under these circumstances, fair value coincides with market prices. "By marking to market in good times allows management to increase their risk taking and financial vulnerabilities tend to build up in the system. These are not properly costed," he said. "However, when markets drop, these financial vulnerabilities surface, which causes management to change its strategy and again fair value amplifies the cycle." The paper argues that fair value brings about a downward spiral of values whenever the markets are illiquid or when actively traded markets are no longer rational. This is because mark to market takes into consideration market conditions at a specific time and therefore, the income statement is significantly affected by large fluctuations in the markets. Further, fair value appears to exacerbate pro-cyclical behaviour of financial markets. Koster said he is not against fair-value accounting. He stressed it as "absolutely critical" but added: "What I am saying is that we have to make sure there is a market. Mark to market needs to have a market and no one ever thought the market would be like this." In the current illiquid markets, he said, using fair-value accounting can severely affect banks in the following ways – capital is artificially eroded even in cases where solid fundamental credit performance is unchanged; the lending capability of a bank is reduced; and the accounting drives economic outcomes, including reduced availability of consumer and small business credit and a negative impact on the health of individual institutions while not reflecting economic reality. Koster said, so far, the response to his proposal in general has been "quite positive". But he acknowledged that there are also many who have been against it. "You have some who are obviously very much against it more so in Europe than in Far East," he said. "Europe would be very hesitant that is because the IASB (International Accounting Standards Board) had already been told to make an adjustment something that they are not too happy with. However, in the US, the FASB (Financial Accounting Standards Board) has relaxed some of the laws and allows comp