While half the world was preoccupied with the summit bringing together Presidents Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping in China, the other half was eagerly awaiting the release of the controversial video game Grand Theft Auto VI (GTA 6). And while the summit ended last Thursday without causing any major political upheaval, the game, released on the same day, stirred a storm of controversy and concern over its content and potential impact on human beings who, in one troubling aspect of modern civilisation and technological progress, have become not merely a source of profit, but subjects of experimentation and reshaping.
What deserves attention is not simply the enormous anticipation surrounding the game, but the world it opens up to millions of players. It is a world of crime, violence, theft, drugs and lawlessness, where players do not merely watch events unfold, as audiences do in cinemas. Instead, they become participants, controlling characters, determining their actions and immersing themselves in a virtual experience that can keep them engaged for hours.
"GTA 6 may be a remarkable technological and artistic achievement and achieve extraordinary commercial success. But success does not place any cultural product beyond scrutiny."
There is nothing new about art exploring crime, violence or sex. Literature, theatre and cinema have done so for centuries. What is new is the extraordinary scale of today’s entertainment industry and the technology that has given it unprecedented access to people’s lives. It can now create interactive worlds in which the boundaries between watching and participating become increasingly blurred, as do those between behaviour people reject in real life and actions they enjoy performing in a virtual setting.
This raises a question that goes far beyond GTA 6: Is the entertainment industry merely reflecting changes in society, or is it increasingly helping to shape them, redrawing the boundaries between acceptable and unacceptable behaviour, between freedom and responsibility, and between moral values inherited over generations and what is now presented as liberation and modernity?
Over recent decades, cinema, television, streaming platforms and video games have undergone profound changes in their content. Sexual scenes once subject to strict restrictions have become more frequent and explicit. Violence that once shocked audiences has become a recurring source of excitement and entertainment. Same-sex relationships and lifestyles that conflict with religious beliefs and social traditions in many societies have also gained greater visibility, sometimes as subjects of debate and sometimes as familiar features of contemporary life.
These issues cannot all be placed in the same moral or legal category, nor can we ignore the different ways societies view them. What deserves examination is how controversial subjects, through repeated exposure on screens, can gradually become familiar, no longer provoking the same questions or objections.
The greatest danger posed by the entertainment industry may not lie in openly encouraging certain behaviours, but in gradually changing how people perceive them. What seemed shocking yesterday may become familiar today, and what once provoked objections may tomorrow be regarded as just another choice. This does not mean that everything people see on screen translates into behaviour in real life. But repetition can influence perceptions of what is common or socially acceptable, particularly when messages are associated with pleasure, excitement and admiration for the characters presenting them.
Defenders of the entertainment industry may argue that art is not an institution for teaching morality, that creators have the right to portray every aspect of human life, including its darkest sides, and that video games are fictional worlds whose players can distinguish fantasy from reality. These arguments cannot simply be dismissed. Art that portrays nothing but virtue may lose its ability to explore human complexity, just as depicting crime does not necessarily mean glorifying it.
"There is a striking paradox in societies spending enormous sums and enacting laws to combat violence, crime and protect children, while celebrating the commercial success of entertainment products that turn violence and criminal activity into exciting experiences. "
Yet there is a difference between exposing the ugliness of crime and turning its commission into a source of pleasure. There is also a difference between exploring a controversial social issue and presenting one position as an unquestionable truth everyone is expected to accept. It is precisely here that the entertainment industry’s responsibility comes into focus, particularly when its products reach millions of young people whose understanding of the world is still developing.
There is a striking paradox in societies spending enormous sums and enacting laws to combat violence, crime and protect children, while celebrating the commercial success of entertainment products that turn violence and criminal activity into exciting experiences. This does not mean violent video games necessarily turn players into criminals. Research has not conclusively established such a link. It does mean that society has every right to question the messages its children receive and where the boundaries should lie between creative freedom and social responsibility.
The entertainment industry has become an immense cultural and economic force, no longer simply a means of passing the time. It helps shape tastes, language, perceptions and perhaps even how people understand themselves and others. Subjecting it to criticism is not an attack on art, technology or freedom of expression, but an exercise of society’s right to question what is offered in the name of progress and modernity.
GTA 6 may be a remarkable technological and artistic achievement and achieve extraordinary commercial success. But success does not place any cultural product beyond scrutiny. Not everything technology enables us to experience should be accepted without question, nor does everything attracting millions necessarily become a measure of what is right or desirable.
The fundamental question remains: If the entertainment industry possesses an unprecedented ability to redraw the boundaries between what is permitted and forbidden, who has the right to draw them? Should we leave that responsibility to market forces and sales figures, or should societies, with their values, experiences and beliefs, retain a voice in deciding what kind of world they wish to live in?
And one final question, addressed directly to parents: What will you do now that GTA 6 has arrived at your doorstep?
---
Abdul Hamid Ahmad is a UAE Writer and Columnist