Dubai: The Dubai Civil Court of First Instance ruled that a doctor and a private hospital jointly pay Dh1.5 million in compensation to a patient who suffered permanent disability following surgery to treat spinal curvature. 

This decision came after the Medical Liability Committee and the Higher Committee proved that there was a serious medical error represented in the failure to temporarily stop the surgical intervention when significant changes were discovered in the nerve monitoring signals, which resulted in injury to the spinal cord and her inability to walk independently.

The details of the case go back to the patient’s visit to the hospital for treatment of a curvature of the spine. After examinations and tests, it was decided to perform surgery to correct the curvature. 

The operation lasted longer than expected, and the patient was transferred to the recovery room, but she did not regain consciousness despite attempts to wake her up. The examinations the following day showed that she had suffered two strokes in the right and left lobes of the brain, while a second operation was performed on her to remove some screws.

Over time, it became clear that she was suffering from severe weakness in her lower limbs and was no longer able to stand or walk independently, so she began a long treatment and rehabilitation journey, before her condition stabilised at a permanent motor disability.

According to the report of the Medical Liability Committee of the Dubai Health Authority, a serious medical error was established, stemming from a profound ignorance of established medical principles. The doctor should have halted the surgical procedure immediately upon the onset of nerve signal loss and blood pressure drop, and worked to identify and treat the underlying causes before proceeding, instead of continuing the procedure as the patient's medical indicators deteriorated. 

The Higher Committee for Medical Liability upheld this assessment, confirming that the medical care provided by the doctor did not meet approved medical standards and that he erred in failing to temporarily stop the procedure upon detecting the significant changes in the physiological neurological monitoring signals.

The report concluded that the error resulted in a spinal cord injury, which caused a permanent disability estimated at about 60% of the functional capacity of the lower limbs. The forensic report also confirmed that the patient became confined to a wheelchair, could not stand or walk on her own, and needed moderate assistance in her daily life activities.

The patient filed a civil lawsuit demanding compensation of Dh10 million for the material and moral damages she suffered, noting that she lost her job and was unable to live a normal life or be self-reliant in her daily needs.

The court found that the elements of medical liability were present, namely error, harm, and causal relationship, and estimated the compensation for these damages at Dh1.5 million, and obligated the doctor and the hospital to pay it jointly.