The Al Ain Court for Civil, Commercial and Administrative Cases ruled that a person must pay AED56,300 to a man. The amount includes the return of AED51,300 obtained through a fake online advertisement for the sale of distinctive vehicle number plates, and AED5,000 in compensation for material and moral damages, in addition to fees, expenses and legal costs.

According to court records, a man filed a lawsuit seeking the return of the money taken from him and compensation of AED40,000. He said the defendant had conspired with an unknown person to publish a fake advertisement for the sale of distinctive vehicle number plates and had lured him into transferring money. The defendant then took the money without transferring ownership of the number plate or returning the funds. The plaintiff explained that the defendant had been criminally convicted in connection with the incident and sentenced to one month in prison and deportation from the country. He said the defendant’s actions caused him material and moral harm. In support of his claim, he submitted a copy of the criminal judgment, proof that he had been notified of it, and a certificate confirming that no appeal had been filed.

The court explained that a final criminal judgment is binding on the civil court regarding matters necessarily decided in relation to the occurrence of the act common to both cases, its legal description and its attribution to the perpetrator. Therefore, the civil court may not re-examine these matters or issue a ruling that contradicts what has been established in the criminal proceedings.

The court pointed out that the defendant’s conviction for obtaining the plaintiff’s money through electronic fraud became final because no appeal was filed against the ruling, establishing fault that gives rise to civil liability.

Regarding the request for the return of the money, the court explained that the law requires anyone who takes another person’s money without a legitimate reason to return it, or its equivalent value. The documents showed that the plaintiff transferred AED51,300 after agreeing to purchase a distinctive vehicle number plate, but ownership was not transferred and the amount was not returned.

The court added that the amount taken was proven by documentary evidence, while the defendant did not appear to provide proof of repayment or discharge of liability. This led the court to conclude that he remained liable for the amount and that the claim for its return was based on sound legal and factual grounds.

Regarding compensation, the court affirmed that its assessment is linked to the loss suffered by the victim and the profit he was deprived of, provided this was a natural consequence of the harmful act. The court also took into account the circumstances of the incident and the evidence presented.

The court explained that the loss of the money deprived the plaintiff of the use and benefit of his funds while they remained with the defendant without a legitimate basis. It also caused moral harm in the form of anxiety and suffering resulting from his exposure to fraud, fulfilling the elements of civil liability: fault, damage and causation.

The court awarded AED5,000 in compensation for material and moral damages, taking into account the circumstances and nature of the incident. As a result, the total amount payable by the defendant was AED56,300, including the original claim and compensation.