Who are we to judge 'misyar' couples?

Each person is different, and they have their priorities

My article about "misyar marriages" - where women have no rights and men have no obligations - and they just get together for companionship and sex received a mixed reaction from our readers.

However, the majority of comments were criticism and anger from all women and men who accept to get into such relationship.

I personally don't believe in such marriages. And don't think it should be considered as a marriage. However, when I spoke to the former marriage counselor at Dubai Courts, I was shocked by the things she said.

There are many women living alone with no men in their lives. Majority of women are rich and capable of taking care of themselves financially.

They are widowed or divorced, and they have grown up children who in most cases are either married and busy with their own lives or travelling abroad for higher education.

These women have almost everything in life. The only thing they seek is to have male's companionship. They don't want to have illegal affairs. They want to get married.

Unfortunately, they do not get the proper marriage proposal in which their husbands can be with them all the time.

They agree to such situations because many of them don't want the husband to be around all the time either. They have their children with them, thus, they seek this companionship only for a few times a week.

The counselor said that many of these "misyar marriages" have turned into normal marriage after sometime as both the husband and wife feel they want to be together more often. A large number of such couples start to have children too.

I don't think it is a good idea to judge these women or men. I don't want to drag religion into this topic either. After all it is what each person believes.

When they get into such relationship, I am sure they know the consequences very well.

We should never try to imagine ourselves in their shoes. Each person is different, and they have their priorities.

If this kind of marriage provides these men and women with the kind of comfort they want, then why not?

 

  • Twitter

Comments

  • Mohd Rizwan Alam 18 September 2010 19:51 0 0
    Even the very idea of misyar marriage generates an ordeal within me. It is an outome of misconception and misinterpretation of the flexibility of social institution of Islam. This will further promote polygamy resulting in plight of women.
  • kaif 4 September 2010 00:13 0 0
    Perhaps people should research more and get themselves informed about mu'ta marriages which were allowed for a period of time before being disallowed after the Prophet's (PBUH) death. If this was to be re-instituted it would provide a legal framework for companionship of the type talked about in this article with a basis in shari'a. At the same time if 'misyar' arrangements work then I'm all for them.
  • Suniana Mahmud 3 September 2010 11:40 0 0
    Yes, you're absolutely right. Who are we to judge those choosing misyar marriages? Just as who are we to judge those opting to marry non-Arabs...right?
  • Hamza 3 September 2010 09:41 0 0
    Such marriages' very foundation is based on satisfying one's animalistic carnal urges. What example is this setting for society and youths with impressionable minds. Many things which are not punishable are morally far worse than many things which are punishable. I rest my case because I am disgusted.
  • Ali Asad 1 September 2010 12:08 0 0
    I'm surprised you didn't discuss mut'a marriage in your article about misyar. Whereas misyar has really no basis in the Quran or tradition, mut'a has both a Quranic basis as well as traditions supporting it (It was definitely allowed for some point in time but there is disagreement about whether it was then disallowed). In mut'a, there are basic rules to protect the woman, such as the right to set any conditions, and have a child provided for by the man. Something to research more perhaps?

Have your say

Comments submitted by third parties on this site are the sole responsibility of the individual/s whose content is submitted. DMI accepts no responsibility for the content of comment/s, including, without limitation, any error, omission or inaccuracy therein. Please note that your email address will NOT appear on the site.

By submitting your comments you agree to this website's Terms & Conditions

Videos

Most Popular in Columns

Latest jobs available

More jobs on Emirates 24|7

Follow
Emirates 24|7

Follow
Emirates 24|7
Google+ Facebook Twitter RSS

Shared on Facebook

Most Popular on Emirates 24|7

Forex Rates

  • GBP 5.64 +1.984%
  • EUR 4.71 +1.303%
  • INR 0.08 -1.024%
  • PKR 0.05 +5.594%

Editor's Choice

In Case You Missed It ...