Dubai: Who should fix the hole in the wall, or the leaking pipe in a rented apartment – the landlord or the tenant? A small issue can become a reason for a long drawn-out dispute, if the terms aren’t clearly laid out and understood.

Here’s what to know about rental repairs in Dubai, who is responsible, and – when there’s no option left – how to escalate a dispute to the authorities.

What does the law say?

Dubai’s rental legislations lay out the general responsibilities for both landlords and tenants.

To highlight who must bear the cost of repairs, Imran Khan, legal consultant at I K Lawyers, referred to Article 16 of Dubai Law No. 26 of 2007 Regulating the Relationship between Landlords and Tenants, as amended by Law No. 33 of 2008. He said: “The landlord is generally responsible for maintaining the rental property and repairing defects or damage that affect the tenant's intended use of the property, unless otherwise agreed in the tenancy contract. Tenants are generally expected to take care of routine maintenance, such as replacing light bulbs, cleaning AC filters and keeping the property in reasonable condition.”

The distinction arises when assessing the significance of the repair – usually, minor, daily maintenance is the tenant’s responsibility, while major repairs and structural renovations fall under the landlord’s purview.

Khan added that Article 19 of Dubai’s rental law also makes it clear that tenants must not make any changes, or conduct any renovations or maintenance works without the landlord's permission. Moreover, such changes can be done only after obtaining necessary approvals from relevant authorities.

Can a landlord refuse to repair damage caused by a tenant?

A landlord is well within his/her rights to refuse to bear the cost of a repair, however, if the reason for damage can be traced back to the tenant, with sufficient evidence.

Khan said: “Where the damage is attributable to the tenant's negligence, misuse, deliberate conduct or failure to comply with their contractual obligations, the landlord may hold the tenant responsible for the repair costs.”

Article 17 of Dubai’s rental law places responsibility on the landlord for defects, damage and deterioration that are not the tenant's fault. Conversely, a tenant may be held liable for damage caused by their own actions or negligence.

Khan shared an example: “If a tenant damages a door, breaks a window or causes plumbing damage through improper use, the tenant may be required to bear the reasonable repair costs.”

What kind of evidence is required to show proof that one party is at fault?

In the example mentioned above, and at all times in general, the allegation that the tenant is at fault must be backed up by solid evidence. Khan said: “The landlord should have reasonable evidence establishing that the damage was caused by the tenant, before seeking compensation.”

In the case of a dispute over such issues, Dubai’s Rental Disputes Centre (RDC), a specialised judicial body under the Dubai Land Department (DLD) that is responsible for resolving all disputes between landlords and tenants, considers the following determining factors to decide which party will bear the cost of repair:

  • Check-in/check-out reports: The RDC assesses whether the item was already deteriorating or damaged at the time of handover. This is why a thorough inspection and photographic evidence is important during the move-in process.
  • Nature of the issue: The RDC analyses whether the failure or damage occurred because of issues related to internal mechanics or because of external impact. In the former case, the landlord would need to resolve it, and in the latter case, the tenant.
  • Technician assessments: The RDC receives feedback via independent, written reports from licensed contractors, who detail exactly why the system failed or the issue occurred.
  • Notice timelines: The RDC checks if the tenant was negligent in reporting the issue on time, and if the delay led to the issue deteriorating. If so, the tenant may be liable for related costs.

⁠Can a tenancy contract oblige tenants to pay for repairs?

Article 16 of Dubai’s rental law expressly states that the landlord’s maintenance responsibility applies ‘unless the parties agree otherwise’. Therefore, the tenancy contract can allocate certain maintenance obligations to the tenant.

Often, Ejari-registered contracts may include a ‘minor maintenance clause’ in their addendums. For instance, a contract may explicitly state that the tenant must pay for any repair under Dh500, while the landlord must cover the cost of anything above that amount.

However, while the tenancy contract offers some flexibility and a cost-sharing avenue for repairs, there are limits in place. Landlords cannot wilfully shift the entire responsibility of maintaining the property to the tenant.

Khan explained: “If the tenancy contract expressly transfers all maintenance responsibilities to the tenant, the starting point under Article 16 changes, because the law recognises the parties' right to agree otherwise. The important consideration is that such an arrangement should be clearly stated in the contract and understood by both parties before signing.”

He added that this is why, it’s important for new tenants to “carefully review any maintenance clause rather than assume that all repairs will automatically be the landlord's responsibility”.

How can landlords and tenants avoid rental repair disputes?

Khan offered landlords and tenants practical precautions that can help them avoid disputes, when it comes to repairs:

  • Conduct a thorough inspection: Before moving in, document the property's condition, including photographs and videos, before handing over or taking possession.
  • Read the fine print: The tenancy contract should distinguish between minor maintenance, major repairs, structural defects and tenant-caused damage. Make sure this information is laid out clearly so that there is no room for misunderstanding.
  • Don’t wait to highlight a problem: Tenants should notify landlords or property managers in writing as soon as a defect or maintenance issue arises.
  • Do another walk-through before moving out: Conduct a final inspection when the tenancy ends and record any damage or outstanding maintenance issues before returning the keys.

If both the landlord and tenant cannot resolve a dispute amicably, either party may approach Dubai’s Rental Disputes Centre for mediation. Learn how to file a dispute here.